
blue_canary
- November 2nd, 2006
I wish I could take credit for this, but I can't. Someone from the Television Without Pity Message boards expressed my feelings about Lost better than I ever could:
What Jack should have said to Ben.
"So, Ben, old buddy, old pal, let me get this straight.
"You find out you have a spinal tumor, two days before the crash of a passenger plane that includes a spinal surgeon among its passengers.
"You need me to operate on you.
"So: rather than rush to the site of the crash, and offer what help you can, and along the way tell me that you need a spinal surgeon, you screw around with us for more than three months.
"You infiltrate us with spies, and steal away people in the night, and kill a few of us while you're at it, and kidnap the pregnant lady.
"And still you don't tell us.
"And even as this tumor continues to grow, along your vertebrae, you manage to get yourself captured by us. And rather than admit THEN who you are, you claim to be a rich balloonist named Henry Gale, and keep up this silly imposture even in the face of torture.
"And then you escape.
"And then you capture three of us, and cage me, and do I don't know what the hell else to Kate and Sawyer, for days and days on end, because, as you tellme now, you wanted to break me; you wanted me 'willing' to help you.
"Here's a news flash for you, Pilgrim.
"You're an idiot.
"Had you shown up at the site of the crash and told me about your problem, I would have helped you. I'm a Doctor. It's what I do.
"Had you shown up at any time during that first month and told me about your problem, I would have helped you. I'm a Doctor. It's what I do.
"Had you told me, at any time during those weeks you spent as our prisoner, about your problem, I would have helped you. I'm a Doctor. It's what I do.
"Even when you captured us, and dragged us all the way over here to this little moonie community of yours, and told me about your problem, without indulging in all of this bullshit, grade-school brainwashing of yours, I would have helped you. I'm a Doctor. It's what I do.
"I never had to LIKE you, you bug-eyed little prick. I'm a Doctor. It's what I do.
"Now, even though you've proved yourself not just a sadist and a paranoid, but an exceedingly stupid one -- since all this time you spent forcing your people into wearing fake beards and so on, that tumor's been continuing to eat at your spine like a carcinomic Pac-Man, and you've been reducing your chances of survival on a daily basis -- I can only say that, yes, you shmuck, you idiot, you bastard, you pop-eyed dictator, I will operate on you. I'm a Doctor, Einstein. It's what I do.
"But since you want me MOTIVATED TO DO MY BEST, you will answer this one simple question, first.
"Ready?"
"Okay. Here's the question.
"(Deep breath)
"WILL YOU PEOPLE JUST STOP WITH THE ENIGMATIC BEHAVIOR FOR FIVE MINUTES ALREADY
AND TELL US WHAT THE F--- IS GOING ON, ON THIS ISLAND?"